UtahOC.com Blog
Salt Lake City's Eyelid Surgery Specialists
October 16, 2011 by Dr. Matheson Harris

Botox vs. Dysport: Is there a difference?

We now have 2 good products on the market for smoothing out dynamic wrinkles: Botox and Dysport. Both are forms of botulinum toxin, a potent chemical that blocks signals at the junction between nerves and muscles. Botox (onabotulinum A), has been around for about 30 years and was initially developed to treat disorders of muscle spasm, such as frequent uncontrolled blinking (blepharospasm). Doctors noted that their patients who received Botox around the eyes had decreased wrinkles, an unexpected benefit of the treatment. An enterprising pharmaceutical company, Allergan, sought a cosmetic indication from the FDA. Botox Cosmetic was introduced to the market, approved for treatment of glabellar wrinkles (those vertical lines between your eyebrows). As is often the case, doctors experimented with injecting Botox in many areas of the face and today it is administered all around the eyes, face and lips.

In 2009, a second product came on the market called Dysport (abobotulinum A), which is very similar chemically to Botox. Many doctors have now gained experience with both medications, but which one is better? Patients who have tried both often prefer one over the other stating that one has a faster onset or lasts longer. A double blind randomized trial (the gold standard for research) was conducted in which patients were injected at the crow’s feet on one side of their face with Botox and the other side with Dysport. They were photographed at the time of injection and at 30 days after. They were also asked to rate which side they liked better. Among the 90 patients studied, they rated Dysport better 2/3 of the time and the researchers also rated Dysport as better for smoothing crow’s feet than Botox. The difference was mainly noted when patients were smiling very vigorously. At rest no difference was noted. In other studies, the risks and side effect profiles were equivalent.

In my experience, Botox and Dysport both work well. Patients who have used both comment that Dysport seems to have a quicker onset (1-3 days vs. 3-7 days), but that hasn’t been universal. Dysport can be slightly cheaper as the company that distributes it in the US often offers rebates to the patients. If you have been using Botox and it is working well for you, I’d continue with it. Occasionally people develop a tolerance to one drug and then you could switch over to the other and likely still get good results again. If you have never tried either, the choice is yours. They both work well and are safe.

If you are interested in trying Botox or Dysport, call our office for a consultation at 801-264-4420.

Share

Tags:

  •   •   •   •   •
October 13, 2011 by Dr. Matheson Harris

Got Dry Eyes? Here are 3 reasons why and 7 ways to treat it.

One of the most common complaints I hear in my office is, “My eyes feel dry.” Many people get that scratchy, irritated feeling to their eyes and know what the problem is. Even more people, however, come in complaining of a whole host of eye symptoms, not knowing that many of them are caused by dry eyes. These include blurred vision that improves with blinking, “tired eyes” or “eye strain”, eye pain, light sensitivity and frequent tearing (a reflex due to dry eye sensation). Yes, even eyes that feel wet a lot can be dry. Let’s first talk about why we tear, then why our eyes are dry, and lastly, what we can do about it.

First, it is important to know that our tears are crucial for good vision. The first thing light hits when it reaches your eye is the tear film on the surface of your cornea. The cornea is like the front window to the eye and the tears are like a polish on that window. With each blink, the eyelid spread a smooth layer of tears across the cornea. This light is then focused by the cornea and lens onto the retina, forming an image. When the tears dry out on the cornea, they leave a bumpy, irregular surface that distorts the light coming into the eye and makes the image blurry. If the tears are continually drying out between blinks, the surface of the cornea becomes constantly irregular due to dead and dying corneal surface cells. This often triggers a reflex to produce lots of tears, so many that our tear drain system is overwhelmed and the tears drain down our face. When we see this in the clinic, we diagnose dry eyes.

The tear film is made up of oil, water and mucus

Our tears are made up of 3 components: oil, water and mucus. The watery part is made mainly in the lacrimal gland which is in the upper outer part of our eye socket under the upper eyelid. There are also many smaller glands on the insides of our eyelids. The skin on the inside of our eyelids makes mucus and rows of glands on our eyelid margins, just behind the eyelashes, make the oil. All three of these components have to be present in the right amounts to make tears work. Without water, the tears gum up and you get eye matter. Without oil, the tears dry out very rapidly between blinks. Without mucus, the tears are too thin and don’t cover the eye well.

This brings us to the causes of dry eyes:

  • Lack of tear production. This happens due to age, inflammation of the tear glands (such as in Sjögren syndrome), hormonal changes causing less production and loss of reflex tearing.
  • Excessive tear evaporation. Excessive evaporation can occur due to tears having not enough oil (usually due to blockage of the oil ducts) and not blinking enough (common when using the computer or reading).
  • Eyelid problems that prevent the tears from being where they need to be. Eyelid problems also lead to dry eye. These include poor blink due to a facial nerve problem (i.e. Bell’s palsy, facial or head injury), eyelid deformities, eyes not closing after over-aggressive eyelid lifting, and in cases where the eyes protrude, such as thyroid eye disease.

So what can be done about it?

  • Get properly diagnosed by an ophthalmologist who knows dry eyes. They will do this by looking at your eyes with a microscope, analyzing your tears with special drops and other tests, and looking at the health of your corneal surface. They will also examine the eyelids to ensure you blink and close the eye appropriately.
  • Use artificial tears. Nearly all types of dry eyes benefit from extra tears. They need to be used often, at least 4 times daily and up to every 10-30 minutes in severe cases. There are many different viscosities of tears. The thicker they are, the longer they’ll last, but thicker tears tend to blur the vision for a while after they are given. Tear ointments are also helpful, especially at night as they can significantly blur the vision when used during the day.
  • Keep your natural tears around longer. Plugs that block off the tear drains in your eyelids will keep you from swallowing away all those tears as they drain into your nose. In more severe cases, we often permanently close off the tear drains, which can greatly improve the eye surface. Your natural tears can be enhanced by taking omega-3 supplements.
  • Practice good eyelid hygiene. Warm compresses on the eyelids to helps oils to flow out more easily into the tears. Lid scrubs with mild baby shampoo and warm water along the eyelash margin will also keep the oil flowing and keep matter from accumulating in the eyelashes.
  • Prevent excess evaporation. Blocking out moving air can reduce evaporative tear loss. This is done by wearing close fitting sunglasses during the day and even special moisture goggles to bed at night. Avoid sleeping under a ceiling fan or blowing the air conditioning at your eyes while driving.
  • Reduce or eliminate contact lens wear. Contact lens wearers can use tears or “re-wetting solution” to keep the eyes more moist and improve lens wear comfort. Never wear them overnight and clean them often, no matter what the lens manufacturers say.
  • In special cases, treat inflammation. In a small number of people with inflammation of the tear producing glands, eye drops like Restasis can help produce more tears. In my view, this medicine is over-prescribed in this country and few patients truly get a benefit from it, so caveat emptor.

Dry eye is common and annoying, but can be readily treated and may improve your vision and overall eye comfort. If you have questions or would like a consultation, call our office at 801-264-4420 or email me at [email protected].

Share

Tags:

  •   •   •   •   •
October 2, 2011 by Dr. Matheson Harris

10 Myths About Your Eyes that You Can Set Straight

One of the best parts of being a doctor is talking to patients and putting their minds at ease about concerns they have. It is always nice to turn their worry into a sigh of relief (I wish that was always the case). Many of the concerns brought up by patients are based on common myths about the eyes that have been propagated and repeated over the years. Here are the top 10 myths I hear about and hope to debunk once and for all. I wish everyone’s eye problems were this simple.

#10: “Reading in low light or with very small print will damage your eyes.” The eye is more like a camera than you think. Just as shooting a photograph in low light doesn’t damage your camera, the same holds true for your eye. The picture may be dim and you have to mentally focus more to figure out what you are seeing, but the eye doesn’t know or care if there is a lot of light or a little, it just adapts to give you the best possible picture. People read by candlelight for thousands of years and did just fine.

#9: “Wearing sunglasses indoors/at night will harm your eyes.” No, you’ll just look like you want to be cool and you may bump into the furniture.

#8: “If I wear my glasses all the time I’ll get dependent on them and my vision will be worse.” Once again, your eyes are very similar to a camera. They have a series of lenses in the front (the cornea and lens) and a sensor in the back with little pixels (the retina). Putting a different lens on your camera or adjusting the focus doesn’t hurt the camera, it just generates differently focused pictures. The same is true with glasses. Their only function is to better focus the light entering your eye on the retina. You want the best lens system you can get all the time so your pictures are always sharp and clear. Your body doesn’t know if the picture is sharp or not, only your brain can interpret this and it has no real capacity to permanently change the physical characteristics of your eyes. You paid a fortune for those fancy frames and lenses. Use them.

#7: “All eye surgery should somehow involve lasers, or it isn’t state of the art.” Marketing mavens love to extol the virtues of lasers because they sound so much more technologically advanced. I have had countless patients express disappointment that I won’t be using a laser to fix their eyelids, because laser surgery is always better. While a few eye surgeries depend on lasers (i.e. LASIK), most are done with the familiar scalpel, scissors and sutures most people associate with surgery. With respect to plastic surgery around the eye, lasers can be used to cut the skin, but so can a scalpel or electrocautery. There is no evidence that any of these devices has any better outcome. One thing lasers do have going for them is that they are much more expensive to operate and maintain than a scalpel, so you can feel good knowing that you paid more for something that is usually no better than the old standby.

#6: “They removed my eye from the socket, fixed it, and put it back in.” Don’t laugh, every eye doctor hears this at least monthly. I once tried to argue with the patient, but I was told he had also seen it in a movie (two witnesses). The eye is directly connected to the brain via the optic nerve. Removing the eye from the socket involves cutting the optic nerve and several muscle attachments. Once the optic nerve is severed it cannot regenerate and the eye is blinded. During surgery we use an eyelid speculum to hold the eyelids open, or a different approach is made through the eyelids or occasionally even through the skull. Every effort is made to keep the optic nerve safe and intact.

#5: “Kids will outgrow crossed eyes.” When a child develops crossing of the eyes (strabismus), an eye exam should be performed as soon as possible. Children have a very small window of time when they can develop binocular vision. This is where their eyes learn to work together to help produce a 3-dimensional image and allow for normal depth perception. Crossed eyes cannot work together and must be corrected. Often, all that is needed is corrective lenses. Sometimes patching or eye surgery is necessary. However, ignoring the problem will most likely lead to one eye losing its ability to achieve sharp vision and making 3-D vision impossible.

#4: “Sitting too close to the TV or computer will damage your eyes.” This myth is dying out, but you still hear it from time to time. Based on what you already know, you can see why this myth doesn’t hold water. Many people do notice that spending a lot of time watching television, reading or looking at the computer makes their eyes feel tired. When we use our eyes intently, we tend to blink less, allowing more time for our tears to evaporate. This leads to dry eye, which will make the eyes become blurred, burn and tear. Closing your eyes or blinking them more will feel good and this is interpreted as “tired eyes.” If this is a problem, try putting in some artificial tears a few minutes before starting to work at the computer and take occasional breaks. Focusing up close also requires muscular effort to bring your eyes inward. The eye muscles get tired after a while and may even ache. Taking break to look off in the distance for a few minutes will usually solve this problem.

#3: “Eating carrots (or some other random food) will make your eyesight better.” While many vitamins are important to the eyes, anyone with a normal diet gets plenty of them. A deficiency of vitamin A, which is plentiful in carrots, can affect your vision, but this is rare nowadays and it isn’t necessary to eat extra vitamin A to keep good vision. A balanced diet is good for you, worrying about one particular vitamin isn’t. (People diagnosed with macular degeneration in its early form can benefit from a select group of vitamins called the AREDS formula, named after the study that proved it, otherwise don’t waste your money).

#2: “Wearing contact lenses overnight is okay, my contact lenses are made to be worn that way.” This is a dangerous marketing ploy that contact lens manufacturers use to lure people into buying their lenses. I have seen plenty of nasty corneal infections, and nearly all involved contact lenses. When pressed, most patients will admit to wearing them while sleeping from time to time. While you might get away with wearing your lenses overnight for awhile, this habit will catch up with you and one day you’ll be in serious pain and in danger of a permanent corneal scar, loss of vision, or even loss of your eye. It can be that serious. Just take them out and sleep easier knowing you aren’t putting your sight in danger.

#1: “My kid isn’t smart because he can’t see,” or “bad vision can cause dyslexia.” Kids can adapt to almost anything, including very poor vision. This myth gets propagated by people selling all manner of eye exercises and vision enhancing devices for kids who are having trouble learning. In reality, most kids have some refractive error, usually far-sightedness, which they gradually outgrow as they mature. Most eyes go from far-sightedness to emmetropia (normal vision not needing glasses). Some kids go past emmetropia and become near-sighted, eventually needing glasses. Regardless of where you kid’s vision is at, he or she is very adept and compensating for any difficulty in seeing. Kids squint, hold text closer, or cheat off their friends when they can’t see the blackboard. They don’t start mixing up their numbers and letters and fail in school. Save yourself some money and hire a tutor or see a guidance counselor. That eye doctor that promises to cure dyslexia with eye exercises is only going to separate you from your money.

Honorable Mention: “‘Sexual activity’ or ‘masturbation’ will make you go blind.” If my kids ever ask, this is completely true. You don’t want to end up blind, do you?

Share
  •   •   •   •   •